Allow me an indulgence, if you will.
I have a memory. '93 - '94, some time round there. I'm at college. The lecturer down the front. It's an art history class, which usually meant sitting watching a film or a documentary and taking notes. But today is different.
I don't remember the inciting incident, although I remember it as a generalised occurrence, but he'd heard about a teaching practice, and decided that we needed to be taught something in turn.
So he stands there and he says something like "You should not ever, let the teachers here attempt to demonstrate how to do something on your drawings. How to draw something correctly. If they insist on doing so, tell them, as politely as possible, to fuck off. Make sure that they get a scrap of paper over yours, or draw in a corner, far from your composition.
"Because the instant that another hand touches your work, it ceases to be yours. When someone else adds a line or a shade, even in demonstration, you have not learned how to do that. You have learned that that person values their vision over yours.
"And as an artist, there is no worse a thing."
I do wonder if this is why I am so uncomfortable with what our current lecturer is attempting to do.
Never mind my discomfort with people sanitising our work in general and trying to spin it as positivity when it blatantly isn't. A younger me would have walked at this point. And I don't know if it's maturity or weakness to be able to swallow the bile and allow her to change my work-- our work - in this way. For while my work may be the only one being changed physically, the context of the cohort as a whole is being altered. It leaves a bad taste in the mouth.
I grew up learning, believing, that to be an artist was a calling. That what we made came from the soul, same as music, same as writing. And to take something that comes from the soul and to change it, to have it changed, it hurts. And it's not right.
As Cesar A. Cruz said, art should disturb the comfortable. It should provide a place to cause thought, to examine your own feelings. Why does this make me feel like this? And to sanitise that strikes me in a way that says my lecturer/curator does not understand art at all.





